Live:
Володимир Анатолійович Тарасенко
Володимир Анатолійович Тарасенко 2 hours тому: «Вітаю! цитата: «як позбутись звички впиватись ногтем в шкіру під час емоційної розмови чи критики а після кусати себе щоб заспокоїтись» Схема допомоги собі в таких випадках прибл»
Віталій Вікторович Бондарчук
Віталій Вікторович Бондарчук 6 hours тому: «Більш важливим і логічним буде віднайти першопричини і саме з ними почати працювати. Тому що, те що ви описуєте є всього лише наслідком і симптомами цих першопричин»
Людмила Петровна Колесник
Людмила Петровна Колесник 6 hours тому: «Вітаю ! Те, що Ви описуєте — коли під час критики чи емоційної розмови хочеться впитися нігтем у шкіру, а потім вкусити себе, щоб заспокоїтися, — схоже на спосіб, яким Ваш організ»
You are reading a translation of this question from the original language: Russian
Question by: jdjdjdj Age: 18

My father’s nagging

Hi. I’m 18. I’m in my second year of university. My father likes to ask provocative questions about me and my life at any convenient or inconvenient moment. For example, he recently asked while just driving me and my half-brother (14) to our grandmother’s house, “So how do you plan to earn a living?” We both said we don’t know. Then he, in his usual way (20% joking, 80% lecturing), started going on about how “you don’t know because you spend all day on TikTok.”

So I came here to ask: Is it really abnormal that at 18 (almost 19), in my second year of university, I have no idea how I’ll earn money in the future? The only income I have right now is my scholarship.
...
What are these ratings?

Question Ratings

Users can vote for questions they like. The best questions are featured in a special section of the website.

You can vote for a question if you found it interesting, well-described, or believe that the psychologists’ answers would be valuable for many others to read.

If you vote for a question, a link to it may later appear on your personal page in the "Liked Questions" section. Negative votes will not be displayed anywhere.

For psychologists, the questions they like will not be displayed on their personal pages.

Want to ask a psychologist a question online for free right now?

Psychologists’ answers

Question author’s reply ·
I’m not asking this question to accuse my father of anything. I love him. I just wanted to clarify this point.
Your father is showing wisdom and foresight. The future is arriving faster than you think, and he is preparing you for it.

There’s a concept called 'Designing Your Life.' Stanford professors suggest using design thinking methods (planning) to plan your career, test different professions, and find work that truly resonates with you.

It’s important to start reflecting now on what you want to achieve in life, what you’re capable of, and what your strengths are. This won’t be an easy question to answer. A degree doesn’t limit you to working in a specific field—statistically, only 27% of people with a completed higher education work in their field of study, and that’s perfectly fine.

For example, if a student studies English, they don’t have to become a teacher; they could work as a manager in a multinational corporation.

Remember, too, that graduating successfully doesn’t guarantee you’ll land a prestigious job or climb the career ladder quickly. Your professional success depends not only on your competence, organizational and leadership skills, but also on your ability to connect with people and work well in a team.

Your personal qualities and determination are the foundation of a successful career and professional fulfillment. Stay curious, work on yourself, and broaden your horizons to build a thriving career in the future.
Dmytro Ratushnyi — psychologist
Dmytro Ratushnyi psychologist
м Дніпро ·
Hello. Well, you probably have some desires and fantasies—even ones not consciously activated—about what you’d like to do and what you’d like to dedicate yourself to. And to your father, you could jokingly reply that your scholarship is your only income right now. Which isn’t bad and is the truth. That’s your job at this stage and the equivalent of earning a living. Studying and receiving a scholarship.

It’s your second year, not your fifth…

Though I suppose this bothers you. I’m curious about what your father’s statements actually imply. If you’d like to explore that further.
Svitlana Matyukha — psychologist
Svitlana Matyukha psychologist
м Кременчук ·
Hello.

Most likely, behind your father’s question lies his anxiety about your future. But if it upset you, it’s worth exploring. It may be connected to the fact that you’re currently going through a period of separation.

I wouldn’t frame your situation solely in terms of “Dad is right or Dad is wrong.” You’re gradually learning to determine for yourself how to live. It’s not always easy for parents to adjust—until recently, you were younger and looked to your father for guidance. Now, it’s important for you to slowly develop your own opinions, make your own decisions, and better understand what *you* truly want.

So, instead of focusing on whether your father is right, I’d suggest asking yourself: How do *you* envision your future? What steps can you take now to gradually move toward your own fulfillment?
Hello!
цитата:
Father's nagging

You could phrase it that way. Or you could look at it differently. It might have been a manifestation of your father’s care for the future of his sons(!)
Care in the sense of his concern about what you spend your time on—
цитата:
“Do you know why you don’t know? Because you spend all day on TikTok.”
—and an attempt to connect two important aspects: independence and responsibility. When I mention the latter, I mean responsibility in every sense of the word.

The truth is, your father acted as best he could and in the way that felt natural and familiar to him. This is about narrative.

Separate from this situation, I’d like you to consider other aspects of your relationship with your father, beyond the love you acknowledge.

Is your father a role model for you in terms of how he has lived his life?

Do you find him personally interesting?

What have you learned from him?

Is there anything you’d like to be like him in?

I think it would be helpful for you to talk to your father about his childhood and youth. What filled those years for him? What did he enjoy? How and thanks to whom or what did he become an adult?
Log in or register to answer.